Fix or Replace: Quick Tips to Choose the Right Move

Got a broken washing machine, a noisy boiler or a fridge that won’t cool? The first question is always the same – do I fix it or do I replace it? It’s tempting to jump straight to a new unit, but a smart look at age, cost and usage can save you a lot of cash.

How to Decide: Repair or Replace?

Start with the age of the appliance. Most modern fridges, dishwashers and ovens last 10‑12 years if you take good care of them. If yours is under half that age, a repair usually makes sense. Check the repair estimate – a good rule is the 50% rule: if the fix costs more than half the price of a new model, consider replacing.

Next, think about energy efficiency. New boilers and refrigerators are far more efficient than older ones. Even a modest boost in efficiency can lower your bills enough to justify a replacement, especially if your current unit is constantly needing service.

Don’t forget the hassle factor. A fridge that’s on its third repair in a year is likely to fail again. If you’re spending time calling technicians, the inconvenience can outweigh the lower price of a repair.

Saving Money with the Right Choice

When you decide to repair, ask the technician for a clear breakdown of parts and labor. Some fixes, like a simple thermostat swap in an oven, are cheap and can be done in an hour. Others, like a compressor replacement in a fridge, are pricey and may involve long downtime.

If you go the replacement route, look for sales, rebates or energy‑star labels. Many retailers offer free removal of the old unit, which cuts down on extra costs.

Finally, keep a simple log for each major appliance. Note the purchase date, any major repairs and the cost. Over time you’ll see patterns – maybe your dishwasher’s motor fails every five years, or your boiler needs a new heat exchanger after eight. That data makes future decisions a breeze.

Bottom line: check the age, compare repair costs to a new price, factor in energy savings, and weigh the inconvenience. With a quick look at these points, you’ll know whether to call a repair tech or start shopping for a replacement.